Why Doraemon like Anime are not Popular in the West?

Nobita Going Out
Scene from Doraemon: 45 Years Later... My Future Self Came to Visit (2005)

Doraemon is a popular anime series of Kodomomuke genre that has been beloved by audiences in Asia for decades. However, it has not gained the same level of popularity in Western countries, particularly English-speaking countries. Doraemon like anime are typically referred to as "kodomomuke anime" or "anime for kids". Other examples of kodomomuke anime include series like Pokemon, Sailor Moon and Crayon Shin-chan. These series have gained a massive following among children and adults alike, both in Japan and around the world, due to their engaging storytelling, lovable characters, and positive messages. In this article, we will explore the reasons behind this discrepancy and examine why Doraemon is so popular in certain Asian countries.

What is Kodomomuke?

Kodomomuke is a Japanese term that refers to anime, manga, and other forms of media that are aimed at children. The term "kodomomuke" can be translated to mean "designed for children" or "aimed at children." Kodomomuke anime and manga typically feature themes and storylines that are appropriate for young viewers. They often contain positive messages about friendship, family, and the importance of hard work and perseverance. The animation style of kodomomuke anime is often colorful and whimsical, with exaggerated facial expressions and physical humor that is appealing to younger audiences.
Some popular examples of kodomomuke anime include Doraemon, Pokemon, and Sailor Moon. These series have gained a massive following among children and adults alike, both in Japan and around the world. While kodomomuke anime is primarily aimed at children, it can also be enjoyed by viewers of all ages. Many adults have fond memories of watching kodomomuke anime when they were young and continue to enjoy the series as a form of nostalgia. Additionally, the positive messages and lighthearted tone of kodomomuke anime can provide a valuable escape from the stresses of daily life for viewers of all ages.

Cultural Differences

One of the primary reasons why Doraemon may not be as well-liked in English-speaking countries is due to cultural differences. The series is heavily influenced by Japanese culture, which may not translate well to Western audiences. Doraemon features themes and humor that are uniquely Japanese, such as the importance of family, education, and hard work. These values may not be as relatable to Western viewers, who may have different values and priorities.
In contrast, Doraemon's themes and humor align more closely with the cultural values of many Asian countries. For example, in India, the show's emphasis on family values and education is highly valued, making it a popular choice for families to watch together.

Animation Style

Another reason why Doraemon may not be as popular in English-speaking countries is due to the animation style. Doraemon and other anime like it often use a distinct style of animation that may not appeal to Western audiences, who may be more accustomed to Western-style animation. Some viewers may also find the exaggerated facial expressions and physical humor in anime to be off-putting or strange.
In contrast, the animation style of Doraemon is highly appealing to viewers in many Asian countries. The characters' designs are cute and whimsical, and the animation brings a sense of lightheartedness to the show's more serious moments. The animation style may also be more appealing to younger viewers, who may find it more relatable and engaging than Western-style animation.

Language Barrier

Another factor that may contribute to Doraemon's lack of popularity in English-speaking countries is the language barrier. Doraemon is originally in Japanese, and while it has been dubbed into other languages, some viewers may prefer to watch shows in their native language. This can make it harder for the show to gain widespread popularity in non-Japanese speaking countries.
In contrast, Doraemon has been dubbed into many different languages in Asian countries, making it more accessible to viewers who may not speak Japanese. This has helped the show gain a wider audience in these countries.

Popularity in Asian Countries

Doraemon is particularly popular in India, Indonesia, Vietnam, Philippines, and Bangladesh. One reason for this is that the show's themes and values align closely with the cultural values of these countries. For example, in India, the show's emphasis on family values and education is highly valued, making it a popular choice for families to watch together. In Indonesia, the show's humor and storytelling have made it a beloved series for generations of fans.
Another reason for Doraemon's popularity in these countries is its availability. The show has been dubbed into many different languages in these countries, making it more accessible to viewers who may not speak Japanese. Additionally, the show has been broadcast on television in these countries, making it easier for viewers to access.

Pros and Cons of Watching Kodomomuke Anime

Kodomomuke anime, or anime aimed at children, like Doraemon, have both pros and cons when it comes to watching them.

Pros:

  1. Positive Messages: Kodomomuke anime often contain positive messages about friendship, family, and the importance of hard work and perseverance. These messages can be valuable for children and adults alike.
  2. Cultural Learning: Watching kodomomuke anime can expose viewers to different cultures and perspectives, helping to broaden their worldview.
  3. Fun and Entertainment: Kodomomuke anime is often entertaining and fun, providing viewers with a lighthearted escape from their daily lives.

Cons:

  1. Age Appropriateness: Some kodomomuke anime may not be appropriate for all ages, containing themes or scenes that may be too mature for young viewers.
  2. Cultural Differences: As mentioned earlier, kodomomuke anime may contain cultural references or themes that may not be relatable to viewers from different cultural backgrounds.
  3. Animation Style: Some viewers may not enjoy the animation style of kodomomuke anime, finding it too exaggerated or unrealistic.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the reasons why Doraemon and other kodomomuke anime may not be as popular in English-speaking countries are complex and multifaceted. Cultural differences, animation style, and language barriers can all contribute to the discrepancy in popularity. However, Doraemon remains a beloved series for millions of fans around the world, with its positive messages, whimsical humor, and cultural significance making it a valuable part of anime history.

Previous Post Next Post